Showing posts with label massachusetts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label massachusetts. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Massachusetts Health Reforms Lead to Higher Costs


With so much emotion flying around the health care debate, it is useful to take a step back and look at the issue empirically. Take, for example, the Massachusetts experiment:

Three years after Massachusetts enacted its sweeping health-reform legislation, rising health costs continue to bedevil the state and threaten to derail reform efforts.


Despite a significant restructuring of the state's health sector and dominance of nonprofit health plans, Massachusetts still has the highest health-insurance costs in the nation, averaging $13,788 for a family, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.


One of the reasons so many people supported the reform effort in Massachusetts is that they were told universal coverage would lead to lower costs. With universal coverage, Massachusetts politicians argued, as many in Washington do today, people would no longer have to pay the medical bills of those who don't have insurance—the "free riders"—and therefore health-insurance premiums would fall, or at least level off.

If more government control can't lower costs, then what is the point?

With health costs are rising so rapidly, Massachusetts has turned to the federal government to cover its shortfalls:

Massachusetts is a problematic model on which to base federal health-care reform because the state relies heavily on Medicaid. Washington in 2008 agreed to provide the state with $10.6 billion over three years as part of its Medicaid waiver request, which allows the state to subsidize insurance for people with incomes higher than Medicaid rules normally allow.


Unlike Massachusetts, the federal government doesn't have a back-up source of funds to help it pay for national health care. Washington might want to see how Massachusetts does in solving these problems before proceeding with a similar model for the country.

We are all now paying for Massachusetts' mistake. Let's not make this a nation wide problem, because there's no one to bail America out if we fail.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

The Baucus Bill Approaches

The Individual Mandate plan has passed through the Senate Finance Committee and is working its way to the floor. The bill would force millions of healthy Americans to purchase health insurance or face hefty fines.

The bill will also be expensive, but will be offset by taxes and reduced Medicare payments:
The $829 billion will be spent mainly in two ways. More than half will go to help lower-income people buy health insurance. Much of the rest—about $340 billion—will expand existing government programs that cover children and the really poor. In other words, the bill's costs are mainly associated with giving insurance to those who don't have it.
To pay for the bill, Baucus is looking in several places. He'll raise about $200 billion by taxing expensive insurance plans, and additional money by fining people who refuse to buy insurance. But the bulk of the money, more than $400 billion, will come from curbing government payments to hospitals and doctors who treat Medicare patients.
One key here is the $400 billion saved from reducing payments from Medicare. Medicare already pays a reduced rate, about 80% of what private insurers must pay. Care providers must either absorb the cost or pass it along to their privately insured customers. Guess which one they choose.
It got a major boost last week when Congress's number crunchers, said it would in fact lower the federal budget deficit by $81 billion over the next 10 years. The bill's overall cost is $829 billion, significantly lower than the other bills floating around Congress.
You know we're in trouble when our best plan is to follow Massachusett's example of forcing everyone to buy insurance while subsidizing those who can't. It's done nothing to control costs, the extra tax burden has hurt their economy, and doctors are over worked and underpaid, forcing some hospitals to close.

Come one guys, let's try a little harder.